Moderation

Ban, Kick, Timeout, or Softban: Which Discord Punishment to Use

Discord gives moderators three punishments. Timeout silences a member for a set time without removing them. Kick removes them but lets them rejoin. Ban removes them and blocks them from rejoining. A softban is a ban followed by an immediate unban, used to delete recent messages. Security Bot lets staff use all four without holding Ban Members or Kick Members.

By Sina, Founder, Security BotUpdated (published )11 min read

The four actions side by side

ActionMember removedMessages deletedCan rejoinDurationNative permission
TimeoutNoNoStill presentIn the app: 60 seconds, 5 or 10 minutes, 1 hour, 1 day, or 1 week. Up to 28 days through a bot or the APITimeout Members
KickYesNoImmediatelyInstantKick Members
Softban (ban + unban)BrieflyUp to 7 daysImmediatelyInstantBan Members
BanYesOptional, up to 7 daysNoPermanent, or timed via a botBan Members

When to use each

  • Timeout for heated members and first offenses. They stay in the server and can read, but cannot post, react, or join voice. Reversible with one click. Use it more than you think.
  • Kick as a warning with consequences, or to remove someone who joined by mistake. Because they can rejoin instantly, it does little against spam accounts.
  • Softban for spam cleanup. It wipes up to seven days of messages everywhere and lets a possibly compromised member return. See what a softban is.
  • Ban for repeat offenders, scammers, and raiders. Choose the message deletion window when banning so the spam goes with them.

Example situations and the action that fits

These are illustrations, not real cases. Each row pairs a common situation with the action that matches it.

SituationActionWhy
Two members arguing in general and one keeps escalatingTimeout, 1 hourThey cool off without leaving; nothing to undo later
A member posted the same link in five channels in a minuteSoftbanWipes the messages everywhere in one action; if the account was hijacked they can rejoin once it is secured
Someone joined by mistake and is confusedKick, or nothingNo offense, no need for a record
A scammer DMing members fake giveawaysBan with 7 days of message deletionThey are not coming back, and the bait goes with them
A regular member's account starts posting crypto scamsSoftban, then contact themLikely compromised, not malicious; the softban clears the spam and keeps the door open
Sixty accounts join in a minute and start posting/lockall, then bulk-ban or let anti-raid punishOne-at-a-time bans cannot keep up; lock first, clean up second

Two patterns are worth stating. Softban fits most spam from established members, because it removes what was posted without deciding the member's future.

A raid is never a one-at-a-time problem. Discord's Members page can ban many selected members at once. On Premium, anti-raid can time out or ban the accounts that joined during the raid window. The lockdown guide covers what to do when the count is in the dozens.

Does Discord IP ban?

Discord's own help center says server bans are based on IP addresses, so there is no separate IP ban to add. A bot cannot see or ban IP addresses directly. Anyone selling an IP ban bot is either just banning the account or asking members to click a tracking link. Determined ban evaders switch networks or accounts. The practical counter is alt detection at join time, not an IP list.

Bots cannot see IP addresses. Discord does not expose them. Treat any bot that claims to as a scam.

What Discord gives you and what a bot adds

Discord ships:

  • The three actions.
  • The audit log, which keeps entries for 45 days and records who did what, but sends no alerts.
  • Bulk ban of selected members on the Members page. It needs Manage Server and Ban Members, and asks for a 2FA code or password.
  • The option to require 2FA for anyone with moderation permissions.

Timeouts and bans can be undone from the member list or the ban list. Timeouts cannot be applied to administrators.

A bot adds the pieces Discord leaves out:

  • A cap on how many bans and kicks one moderator can issue through it.
  • A mod log that stays in a channel your team already reads.
  • A reason and duration attached to every action.

Through Security Bot, while Anti Ban and Anti Kick are on (they are by default), /ban, /softban, and /kick (plus /banid on Premium) are capped. The caps are your anti-nuke ban and kick limits, per moderator per 10 minutes. At the cap, the command is refused until the counter resets.

A ban given with a time: lifts on its own when the time runs out. Bans and kicks made natively in Discord are counted by anti-nuke itself, and the account is punished when it reaches the limit.

How to run these actions safely

The native way requires giving moderators Ban Members and Kick Members on their role. Those permissions work on every member below them, all the time, and a phished moderator account becomes a mass-ban tool. The safer way is a bot that performs the action with its own permission, checks a cap first, and logs the result.

  1. Open the Moderation page in the Security Bot dashboard.
  2. Pick a moderator and grant the commands they need: Ban, Kick, Softban, Mute, Clear, Lock.
  3. Remove Ban Members and Kick Members from their Discord role.
  4. Set a moderation log channel on the Logging page.
  5. Keep Anti Ban and Anti Kick on and check their limits. While they are on, /ban, /softban, and /kick are capped at those limits per moderator per 10 minutes (defaults: 5 bans, 5 kicks). A stolen moderator account runs out of bans quickly. /mute, /clear, and the lock commands have no cap.

Suggested starting points by server type

These are starting values to adjust after a week of reading your logs, not product defaults. Remember how the limit works. A native ban that brings a member's count to the limit is punished. The bot's commands are allowed up to the limit and refused after it.

Small community, under 500 members

Timeouts for nearly everything. A ban and kick limit of 2 or 3, with clear roles as the punishment. A staff member who mass-bans natively then loses their roles rather than their membership. One person holds Ban Members natively as a backup in case the bot is offline. Everyone else moderates through the bot.

Public gaming server

Softban as the default for spam, /mute timeouts for the noisy, and ban with message deletion for scammers. Ban limit 3 and kick limit 3 are a reasonable start. Give moderators Ban, Kick, Softban, Mute, and Clear on the Moderation page and take Ban Members off their Discord role. Keep the moderation log open to all staff so decisions stay consistent across time zones.

Crypto, NFT, or marketplace server

Ban with 7 days of message deletion for every scam post, because a softbanned scammer simply rejoins. Use the ban punishment on the channel and role delete triggers. On Premium, turn on Threat Link Guard so known scam links are deleted as soon as they are posted. Captcha verification makes each throwaway account cost more to get in. Review the moderation log daily.

Command reference

CommandDoesNotes
/ban user:@member [time] [reason] [delete_days]Ban, permanent or timedThe member must be in the server. With time:, the ban lifts on its own. Capped at the anti-nuke ban limit per moderator per 10 minutes while Anti Ban is on
/unban user:<name or ID> [reason]Lift a banTakes a username or a user ID. Also cancels a pending timed unban
/softban user:@member [reason] [delete_days]Ban and unban to delete messagesDeletes 1 day of messages unless you set delete_days (up to 7). Counts toward the ban cap
/kick user:@member [reason]Remove without banningCounts toward the kick cap
/mute user:@member time:1h [reason]Discord timeoutDuration is required, up to 28 days. No mute role is used
/unmute user:@memberRemove the timeout
/clear amount:50Bulk delete 2 to 100 messagesOptional filters for a user, bots, links, embeds, or images. Discord only bulk deletes messages under 14 days old. Not written to the moderation log
/lock, /unlock, /lockall, /unlockallLock or reopen one text channel, or every regular text channelWith time:, a lock lifts on its own. /unlockall reopens only the channels Security Bot locked. See the lockdown guide

Common mistakes

  • Kicking spam accounts. They rejoin with the same invite in seconds. Softban or ban.
  • Banning without deleting messages. The scam link stays up for everyone who scrolls past. Choose the deletion window when banning, or use softban.
  • Giving every moderator Ban Members. Each one is now a mass-ban tool if their account is phished. Grant the command on the Moderation page instead.
  • No reason on the action. Appeals become arguments. Every Security Bot moderation command takes a reason, and it goes in the log.
  • Forgetting the timeout expires. A 28-day timeout on a repeat offender runs out quietly. Ban, or set a reminder.
  • Moderating without 2FA. If the server requires 2FA for moderation, a moderator without it loses their native moderation permissions until they turn it on. Check before onboarding new staff.

Troubleshooting

/ban or /kick fails with a hierarchy or permission error

The target's highest role is at or above Security Bot's role, or the moderator is ranked below the target. Role hierarchy applies to bot commands as well as native actions. Move the bot's role above the roles it needs to act on, and remember that nobody can moderate a member ranked above them.

/ban says "You have reached the ban limit, try again later"

The moderator used up the ban cap. While Anti Ban is on, /ban and /softban (and /banid on Premium) are allowed up to your anti-nuke limit per moderator. The same goes for /kick while Anti Kick is on. The counters reset every 10 minutes.

Nothing else happens. There is no punishment or owner alert for hitting the cap. If your team legitimately bans more than that during a cleanup, raise the ban limit on the Anti-Nuke page. Whitelisting does not raise this cap. The server owner and Administrators ranked above Security Bot are not capped.

A moderator was punished by anti-nuke after a ban wave

They banned natively, through Discord's own menus, and their count reached the ban limit. Check the security log for the trigger. Give their roles back if the punishment was clear roles, and decide whether the limit is too low for your team.

Moving that moderator to /ban stops native bans from counting against them. For a lead admin who must ban natively in bulk, a per-action whitelist entry for Ban skips the native count. But it also removes the protection if that account is ever stolen.

/unban needs an ID I do not have

/unban accepts a username as well as an ID. The moderation log entry for the ban includes the target, and Server Settings, Bans shows every banned account. To copy an ID, enable Developer Mode under User Settings, Advanced, then right-click the user.

A timed-out member is still posting

Discord does not let anyone time out a member with Administrator. The bot also cannot time out a member whose highest role is above its own. The fix is the permission and the role order, not the punishment. Remove Administrator from the role and let them moderate through the bot like everyone else.

Logging and appeals

Bans, unbans, softbans, kicks, mutes, unmutes, and locks run through the bot are written to the moderation log with the moderator, target, reason, and duration. /clear is not logged, and neither is /raid ban on Premium.

Keep the log channel visible to all staff so decisions are reviewable. For appeals, the log is the record: a member who says they were banned for nothing can be checked against the reason in seconds.

A weekly moderation review

Once a week, read the moderation log top to bottom. Look for bans without reasons, the same member timed out three times, and any softban that should have been a ban. Cross-check against the security log for anti-nuke warnings and punishments on staff.

Both logs are ordinary messages in your own Discord channels, so they stay as long as nobody deletes them. Use channel search to look back when a pattern emerges. The logging page describes what each channel receives.

Do this with Security Bot

Discord Moderation Bot: Give staff moderation tools without handing out risky Discord permissions across the server.

Security Bot gives moderators ban, kick, softban, mute, lock, and clear commands. You get per-user access, a cap on bot bans and kicks, and a moderation log. Staff can moderate through the bot without Ban Members, Manage Channels, or Administrator on their role.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between kick and ban on Discord?

A kicked member can rejoin immediately with any invite. A banned member cannot rejoin. Discord says server bans are based on IP addresses.

How long can a Discord timeout last?

In the Discord app you can pick 60 seconds, 5 or 10 minutes, 1 hour, 1 day, or 1 week. Bots and the API can set up to 28 days. It is reversible at any time.

Can a bot IP ban someone on Discord?

No. Bots cannot see IP addresses. A normal Discord ban is the strongest ban there is. There is nothing extra a bot can do.

Do moderators need Ban Members to ban through a bot?

Not with Security Bot. Grant the Ban command on the Moderation page, and the bot performs the ban with its own permission. It is capped at your anti-nuke ban limit per moderator per 10 minutes while Anti Ban is on (the default).

Does banning delete messages?

Optionally. Discord lets you delete the member's messages from the last hour up to the last seven days when you ban.

Can Security Bot time out a member?

Yes. /mute applies a Discord timeout: /mute user:@member time:1h, up to 28 days. On Premium, AutoMod presets can also add a timeout after a rule blocks a message.

How many bans can a moderator issue before anti-nuke stops them?

It depends on the ban limit (5 by default), counted per user and reset every 10 minutes. Native bans are punished when the count reaches the limit. While Anti Ban is on, bans through /ban and /softban are allowed up to the limit and then refused. To allow more bot bans, raise the limit. Whitelisting does not change the command cap.

How this guide was made: drafted with AI assistance, then checked against Security Bot's source code and Discord's official help articles. Spotted something out of date? Tell us in the support server.